FOLLOW US!

Neuhart Cards & Sports Collectibles

We are always buying!

Whether you are a long-term hobbyist or simply rediscovering an old pastime, Neuhart Cards & Sports Collectibles is your first stop for sports cards, supplies, and advice. Our professional staff has over 50 years combined experience in the sports card industry, and we are always happy to advise on the latest release or the newest hot rookie.  

Neuhart Cards & Sports Collectibles is always buying, and our reputation precedes us in the sports cards market place. We buy collections every day – if you have any modern or vintage sports cards please give us a call at 740-417-4877 or visit us at 820 Sunbury Rd Suite 621, Delaware, OH 43015. 


Central Ohio's Finest

Keith Neuhart has been buying, trading, and selling sports cards for over 30 years and made a life long dream come true in 2010 when he opened his first stand alone retail location. He has been, and plans to continue serving the greater Delaware area for many years to come. 

Brian has worked at Neuhart Cards with Keith since March 2014. After being medically retired from the U.S. Army the opportunity presented itself for him to follow a childhood dream of working in a sports card hobby shop so he jumped in head first bringing several years of in-depth knowledge of the hobby from the consumer side! 

Our passion for the hobby and the collector drives us everyday to be the best in the business. When you love sports cards, you'll love us!

Packed house for one of our popular trade nights! All ages are welcome. Free food, drinks, and plenty of giveaways. Follow us on Facebook to find out when we will be hosting the next event. 

Amazing inventory

Whether you are looking for the latest hobby box releases or are in the market to add a single to your collection we have you covered with the area's best selection. We partner with several different distributors to ensure that we have a large selection of hobby boxes to choose from. If are looking for something we don't have in stock we can often have it the next business day. We also strive to constantly add rookies, jersey cards, and autos of the most popular players in sports past and present. Neuhart Cards boasts six showcases full of the latest prospects, the best rookies and many Hall of Famers. If you are looking to add a peice that is more budget friendly we carry several thousand game used, autos, and rookies in our value boxes priced $15 or less!

Home of the 2013 Bowman Kris Bryant Auto Superfractor 1/1!

In April 2015 the 2013 Bowman Chrome Kris Bryant Superfracor 1/1 was pulled from a box purchased at Neuhart Cards. Our small shop gained national recognition from Beckett Magazine as well as sports industry leaders such as ESPN and Fox Sports. The card would go on to be graded in Gem Mint condition and sell for upwards of $50,000, which at the time set a new record for a modern baseball card! We have attached an interview that Brian did with Chris Olds of Beckett below.

Call today! (740) 417-4877
Share by: